50 Cent vs. Eminem - Who Has The Better "Toy Soldier" Song Concept (Poll)

[Jimmy Two-Times™]

 

[the cac mamba]

gotta go with em, that video is pretty compared to his usual soulless music

 

[Carlton Banks]

Fif

 

[TheDarceKnight]

The Em joint has going for it the Proof dedication aspect which was nice. But I always thought the hook was corny.

The 50 joint isn’t in my top 10 on the massacre but I’m still going with 50 because I’ve been listening to a lot of old 50 this month for some reason.

 

[ThirdAct]

Like Toy Soldiers and its video came out before Proof died tho


Like Toy Soldiers has the better beat, one of Em's better beats overall, but automatic points deducted for Em going for the whole song

I can't stand Em's maudlin overly-serious side, shyt is extra corny...plus I thought he was Mr. Big Bad Battle Rapper?

My Toy Soldier is aight, typical 50 shyt, so tie

 

[raoulduke187]

50 easy

Yayo's verse on this

 

[Kal-El]

Ems version is garbage compared to Fifs

 

[Still FloW]

Yayo's verse >>>> Em

 

[Cladyclad]

50 version was on some

I’ll

Then you



Vs

Em corny ass on some

I’ll on u

But when shyt got real dude went





50 & Yayo all day.

 

[Jordan>>LeFrozen]

Em version was touching, especially when you consider what happened to proof.

 

[re'up]

50 killed those verses, that was vintage grimy 50, I liked Eminem's too though, as much as it is melodramatic and somewhat overwrought, I think it holds up.

 

[Toe Jay Simpson]

Em was copping pleas for why he picked on skinny white kids instead of nikkas that actually wanted to do him and his crew harm

 

[mr x]

One of Em's production gems

 

[GetRichOrDieTryin]

Curtis