The Coli Official Boxing Controversial Decision Thread
- Thread starter surv2syn
- Start date
Oscar De La Hoya is one of boxing most "gifted" fighters. I am not talking about talent. I am talking about decisions in his fights.
I believe he lost without question against Sweet Pea.
He never hurt him or landed anything significant. Whitaker was just not given enough credit for his defense in that fight. He really made Oscar look stupid. Pea's jab kept Oscar's timing off all night. Oscar looked like an amateur. Whitaker also was credited with a KD. The judges were not having it though. Nothing at that time was gonna derail the DLH money train.
Oscar also got a gift against Sturm. I believe Oscar beat Tito, but was served poetic justice. I dont know if I would call that a robbery and DLH looked really bytchmade complaining about the decision afterwards. I thought he lost to Quartey...I wouldnt say it was controversial though.
I believe he lost without question against Sweet Pea.
He never hurt him or landed anything significant. Whitaker was just not given enough credit for his defense in that fight. He really made Oscar look stupid. Pea's jab kept Oscar's timing off all night. Oscar looked like an amateur. Whitaker also was credited with a KD. The judges were not having it though. Nothing at that time was gonna derail the DLH money train.
Oscar also got a gift against Sturm. I believe Oscar beat Tito, but was served poetic justice. I dont know if I would call that a robbery and DLH looked really bytchmade complaining about the decision afterwards. I thought he lost to Quartey...I wouldnt say it was controversial though.
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
Winky Wright-Jermain Taylor
I still say Winky won that fight
I still say Winky won that fight
I saw Winky won too. Was it controversial? Everyone always talks about how Winky lost the 12th. Like Winky said though...since he lost the 12th does that mean you give Taylor the whole fight?
Carl Froch-Andre Dirrell
This fight could easily be a draw or even a decision to Dirrell since he actually rocked Froch a couple times during this fight but in no way did Froch win this fight by any stretch of the imagination
This fight could easily be a draw or even a decision to Dirrell since he actually rocked Froch a couple times during this fight but in no way did Froch win this fight by any stretch of the imagination
Paul Williams-Sergio Martinez 1 - The right fighter won yes but I want to know what the 1 judge was smoking to score this fight 119-110?!!! 
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
I guess you could say it was controversial since it was a draw. From the eyes of a 15 year old as I was at the time it just appeared to me that Winky fought a better fight than Taylor over the full fight that's why I say he won. They should've had a rematch
yeah Winky didn't fight like he wanted those belts...thats what the problem..he didnt really go all out in the last round else the belts would have been his
Jesus Is Lord
Give Thanks, Repent, and Forgive
Paul Williams-Sergio Martinez 1 - The right fighter won yes but I want to know what the 1 judge was smoking to score this fight 119-110?!!!
This.
I honestly never understand how judges score a close fight with a margin like that. I mean, how a HONEST judge scores a fight like that?
especially how much of a near classic fight this was...punisher didnt need that bullshyt to taint his hard earned win
I was on another board during the Lara-William fight. Williams was getting his ass beat so bad, people were calling for him to retire after the fight. You here to decision is announced & it's a MD for Paul Williams. Everyone knows Williams lost that.
Last edited:
I thought Dirrell won but knew it was gonna be tough to get the decision.
King P
Legends Never Die
Jermain Taylor got a gift against Hopkins in their first fight.
And Chris John's bytch ass did not beat JMM.
And Chris John's bytch ass did not beat JMM.
i thought taylor did win the first fight 7 rounds to 5...barely though..i do think he lost the hopkins rematch clearly
he also got a mean gift against cory spinks...cory spinks should have been the undisputed middleweight champion that night