[#RNR] REAL nikka REVIEW: Eminem - "MMLP2"

A.V.

reTIreMEnt: THE ALBUM (01/22) ALL DSPs
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
12,883
Reputation
8,214
Daps
42,023
Reppin
#AnyCityGang
MMLP2-Cover.jpg



Iight...As I've stated before, I'm an Em fan. To a degree. Being that I like lyricism, and having the day off today, I took last night to listen to the album another two times & allow me to break this down. One thing about this album is that you gotta be in full on CaC listening mode to appreciate/digest it. If you're listening to any other Hip-Hop and flip from that into throwing this shyt on, it'll have you on some :scusthov: type shyt. You almost gotta put yourself in the same mindframe you were in (as an Em fan) back in 99-01 to even fukk with this shyt. So without further ado...



-------------------------------------------------

1. Bad Guy - On first listen I couldn't figure out if the beat was straight ass or halfway decent...It's cool, when mixed in with the hook, but a little too lighthearted for the subject matter, imo. The concept is dope, but borderlines on rambling a few minutes into the song. Just as you're like :comeon: with the climax already, the beat changes, which is where the real genius of the song begins. Can't tell if Em's truly remorseful/indulging all the thoughts of self-reflection & regret, or if he's just subtly trying to appease the LGBT / PC crowd by having a protagonist type story where he's the victim, but it's dope nontheless. The 2nd half is infinitely more dope when you listen harder and break down the lyrics. Could've made a good outro, but works nicely as an intro.
(3.5/5)




2. Parking Lot (Skit) - When I first heard this, I won't lie, I :gladbron: thinking we were about to revisit "Criminal" and get a similar verse on the following song. It ended as abruptly and unexpected as it started, then the next song came on, seeming out of place with the skit.




3. Rhyme or Reason - Ok, one of my favorite samples...Beat has a dope little bop to it. On first listen the gay ass Yoda voice & other various audiofukkeries threw me off on some :scusthov: shyt, but once again...remembering this is Eminem, at best, a super-lyrical comedian, you take it with a grain of salt and just chalk it up with the Jackie Chan face and enjoy the lyricism. He's talkin his shyt throughout, especially on the second verse with the white devil/horns lines. Seems like he throws a little sub at Jay with the "complain about a Picasso painting" line, not sure if that's a reach or not...yet.
(3/5)




4. So Much Better - Right off the rip, this reminds you of classic Em. The vowel play with the "knew Drake/Lupe" & the million stars he referenced was ill as fukk. After such a long hiatus, it's a little off-putting to hear this guy still rhyme about bytches on the same tip he was on, back in the day, but I guess the real genius in that lies in the fact he labeled the album MMLP2. It allows him to revisit the same subject matter, with the excuse of making a sequel album. The song is ultimately funny for the most part. I can see white girls (stupidly, as always) falling in love with this shyt. The l-l-l-lesbian line, and shyt like that is where the replay value lies...that unexpected blatant fukkery is what makes tracks like this on the album enjoyable. The hook is corny, as is more often than not, but it works. One thing I can say about the album so far is that the lyricism is thought-out, and actually superb, no matter how corny. Sounds like more Jay sublims from the "Girls, girls, girls line to the 99 Problems" reference. They may not be, but shyt like that just makes your ears perk up, knowing the history between Em & Jay, and the regard in which Em holds himself as the top rapper.
(2.5/5)


5. Survival - This is a track I immediately hated when I first heard it a few weeks ago. Coming through the headphones though, I can definitely hear its appeal. The production is dope, even though it blends elements of rock/pop. I can see white people eating this shyt up, no wonder why it's a single. Definitely staduim music. Even though there's quite a few cornball lines scattered throughout. But I guess that's just something you have to expect from this CaC at this point.
(2.5/5)




6. Legacy - Instantly cringed at this song when I heard the subject matter. Come on son, bully anthems still? Blatant PC/suicide victim pandering? Didn't like it much on first listen, even though as usual, the lyrics are there. The production is dope for the concept, definitely has potential single written on it, and at this point it becomes evident that Em is caving to the labels demands. "Reverse heel turn. The bad guy goes good. Public eats it up, and Eminem becomes a media darling, showing his sensitive side." Fat kids, limp wrist fakkits in training, wrist slitters, bulimics, and weirdo kids will tout this as their life-changing coming-of-age track. Funny thing is, it works though. Even though it's clear what the objective is with this track, it's done well. From the progression from somber to revengeful, to the lyricism in the 3rd verse (Brian Dawkins/Lions offense lines & bars after), it's probably one of the better tracks so far.
(4/5)




7. a$$hole - For what it's worth...All I can say is, it's Em. You know what you're getting at his best, and you know what you're getting at his worst. Even if the lyrics are there, some shyt can just be cringeworthy to an extreme. The verses were almost tolerable, but the hook makes this shyt Recycle Bin status. Permanent delete off SD card. Camby, nikka. No colons. Get the fukk outta here. And I'm not even gonna speak on that beat.
(1/5)




8. Bezerk - Man I can't get jiggy with this shyt. No matter how hard I try, I just don't fukk with it. The forced Beastie Boys/Run DMC sound, the corny ass lyrics, the "trying too hard to sound different" hook...Nah. This shyt has FOR CACS ONLY written all over it. Not even wasting my time reviewing. I'll only give this shyt a 2/5 rating because it's slightly more listenable than "a$$hole"...on second thought, fukk that.
(1.5/5)

 
Last edited:

A.V.

reTIreMEnt: THE ALBUM (01/22) ALL DSPs
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
12,883
Reputation
8,214
Daps
42,023
Reppin
#AnyCityGang
9. Rap God - Lyricism is top notch on this track. Few corny parts here & there. Most CaCs won't even realize or understand the OG hip-hop references Em drops in this one, yet still proclaim it as one of the best songs ever. The only part of this track I really wish was taken out was the Fab/Ray J lines, used to transition into the super-fast flow, which is dope in itself. Sometimes the extra emphasis on certain words and extra rhyming lines he throws in just for sake of the rhyme scheme gets played, but...This is what most hip-hop fans ask for. He just overdoes it. Overall, very good track.
(4/5)


10. Brainless - Beat is dope...feeling the intro samples, the dusty & old feeling...Lyrics/subject matter sounding more like classic Em. I don't know how this cat does it, remaining on that middle school content, while making it sound good & not being completely embarrased of himself, but I guess it works. The piano riff in this is disgusting...Sheesh. Drum pattern is definitely ill too. The second half of the 3rd verse, especially the "insert insult here"...pretty slick.
(4/5)


11. Stronger Than I Was - shyt has absolutely no place on this album. I really thought nikkas was playing when they said this shyt made Drake sound like Onyx...God damn. I know he tries to save the song with a few profanities, but fukk that. This shyt is just fukking pitiful. On an album already heavy on the pop side, he could've laid some harder shyt & still been iight. I wanna give this shyt no stars, but I know the CaC coalition will be up in arms, so here you go, you fakkits:
(1/5)


12. The Monster - More pop pandering. Meh. Cool for what it is, but it's definitely played out. And this bytch really just said "monsters under my bed", so :camby:
(2.5/5)


13. So Far... - On first listen I was fukkin dead...This nikka really making poop jokes still? My sense of humor can get juvenile at times though, so I kinda feel this shyt...as I've said a few times before, you gotta put yourself in a different box to listen to this nikka music. I can't listen to Em after Jay, M.O.P. or D-Block...But when you on your 'different' shyt, and just wanna hear some fukk shyt with good lyrics, this nikka got the bases covered. The same leeway you give to Ye when listening to Yeezus, has to be (and has always been) afforded to Em on his solo work. The singing immediately pissed me off, cuz it's MORE deliberate top 40, CaC-pop pandering, but for what it is, it's a cool little joint. The John Madden wordplay mixed in with the humor of this track actually makes the first verse enjoyable. I appreciate the fact that this somewhat addresses more of the reality of his day-to-day life, midlife crisis themes, and the hook actually isn't that bad, it's kinda catchy even though the country twist ain't my thing. The way they sampled during the hook is dope though. The imagery on this is top notch, and the revisiting of "I'm Back" & "The Real Slim Shady" from MMLP is dope too. LMAO @ this nikka saying "they want me to flip at the label but I won't succumb to it..." Riiiiiiiight. But
(3.5/5)


14. Love Game - A lot of cats ain't feelin this shyt. And for what it's worth, I wasn't really feelin it either. But it's funny as fukk that 2 of the games better lyricists can :troll: & catch everyone off guard and put out a track of fukkery instead of that super lyrical miracle high spiritual bullshyt you fakkits expected. Umad? On first listen, I thought Kendrick BODIED Em on his own steez. He almost did Eminem better than Eminem does. But on subsequent listens, Em did both verses he had justice. The first verse, he has hip-hop references that only a nikka who came up on 80's & 90's rap would notice or appreciate. The way he intertwined them with the little story was dope. And the name dropping was not only dope but hilarious. Kendricks verse is the most listenable, and the flow is just ridiculous. I laughed all throughout this whole track. Em's 3rd verse just seemed like he ran in behind Kendrick, not to get outdone on his own track, and rambled at times...but the comedic value (the text message intentionally sent to make the bytch crash her car) is just as up to par with the lyricism. One thing I also took away from this track is that Kendrick singing > Drake singing. Even though his melodies aren't as elaborate or R&Bish, they're definitely more original, soulful and fresh.
(4/5)


15. Headlights - Damn, this shyt is actually kind of bittersweet. Not because of the subject matter...But because throughout, it just seems like Em's coming to terms with the fact he's aging and his moms is mortal, someone probably approaching her deathbed, and wanting to make amends before she passes. The number of disses & personal laundry he aired out towards her over the years greatly outweigh anything he can say on this track, but it's a commendable effort, and cool to see the maturity...albeit from a 40 year old man. The yelling is getting annoying. Even though he's trying to inflect emotion, it kind of has the opposite effect. Overall, cool track. Hook is kinda ill.
(3.5/5)


16. Evil Twin - I could write a fukking whole nother thread on this song, but to sum it all up, I'll just leave it at this: :banderas:
(5/5)



Overall: This isn't a BAD album. But I can definitely see why one would say so. The production's all over the place...Sequencing is good from certain songs to the other, but the overall cohesiveness isn't there. The first half of the album is actually pretty decent, save for Bezerk and a$$hole...And Stronger Than I Was and The Monster coming one after another, make this album close to unlistenable on the first try, which can turn someone off completely and not give it a chance at all. That many POS songs bundled close together can make or break a project, and that's ultimately what keeps this from even being one of HIS best CDs. When people say this isn't MMLP or SSLP, it's easy to defend against that by saying "why would Em go backwards...what do you want, him to stay on the same shyt?" But in actuality, he IS (for the most part) on the same shyt. What I see the problem as, is the cohesiveness of those 2 albums being light years ahead of this one. shyt just don't flow well. Still, the lyricism and novelty of it being an Eminem album is what saves this from being mediocre.

There's not enough here to call it a classic, and one thing about this makes me appreciate efforts like Yeezus and MNIMN more. Ye has the artistic integrity to know when to keep an album short of filler. With so much of this album suffering from overplayed themes, and juvenile humor, Em really could've made this a better album by simply taking out a few tracks. Another Rihanna joint isn't necessary. Neither is a$$hole. Making this album just a LITTLE more "Hip-Hop" production wise would've also done it some more justice. If this is Em's last album however, it's not a bad farewell to the game. At this point, maybe it's the best he can bring us, with the label he's on. It's a back & forth between safe & forced edginess...Youthful carelessness and maturity. Somewhat of a medium. And medium would actually be a perfect word to describe this, in terms of EMINEM albums. Which is why after averaging all the scores from the individual tracks, it still comes out to an overall 3. Something I feel is a perfect rating for this album.
(3/5)

MMLP > SSLP > TES > * MMLP2 > * Relapse > Recovery > Encore
* interchangeable​
 
Last edited:

SunZoo

The Legendary Super Sapien.
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
34,820
Reputation
12,350
Daps
132,764
Reppin
T.L.C.
Dope review, i'm cappin hard for stronger than I was though, it's a song from kims perspective which I didn't catch on the first couple listens. I gotta kinda get into bad guy, I was too anxious to hear joints like legacy and got stuck on evil twin, by the time I got to that shyt I was :banderas:

Getting ready to peep these bonus tracks and throw a couple of these pop tracks in the bushes.
 
Last edited:

Funcrusher

All Star
Joined
Jul 4, 2012
Messages
2,032
Reputation
270
Daps
3,734
Reppin
NULL
It seems those bonus tracks seem perfect to replace the singles except for Rap God. On first listen I had the feeling Interscope made him throw those in, and let him keep the tracks he would've put there instead on the bonus disc. That what I already thought when Survival showed up on the tracklist, when we all now that's a Recovery leftover.
When I get the whole package in 320, I might replace some songs with the bonus tracks to see how that flows.
 

A.V.

reTIreMEnt: THE ALBUM (01/22) ALL DSPs
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
12,883
Reputation
8,214
Daps
42,023
Reppin
#AnyCityGang
It seems those bonus tracks seem perfect to replace the singles except for Rap God. On first listen I had the feeling Interscope made him throw those in, and let him keep the tracks he would've put there instead on the bonus disc. That what I already thought when Survival showed up on the tracklist, when we all now that's a Recovery leftover.
When I get the whole package in 320, I might replace some songs with the bonus tracks to see how that flows.


Seems like the best idea. I'm throwing a$$hole, The Monster, Stronger Than I Was, Bezerk, and possibly Rhyme or Reason in the bushes, replacing them with the Bonus tracks, and seeing how that flows... :lupe:
 

Funcrusher

All Star
Joined
Jul 4, 2012
Messages
2,032
Reputation
270
Daps
3,734
Reppin
NULL
Seems like the best idea. I'm throwing @sshole, The Monster, Stronger Than I Was, Bezerk, and possibly Rhyme or Reason in the bushes, replacing them with the Bonus tracks, and seeing how that flows... :lupe:

I honestly think it's Interscope behind those single shananigans, Eminem in his right mind wouldn't put a song like Monster on a cd called MMLP2. And Survival is obviously a leftover, no artist has ever made a new original song for a game.

Fair review btw, even though it could have done without the whole what kinda mode you're in intro.
 

CASHAPP

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Aug 12, 2012
Messages
26,315
Reputation
-2,514
Daps
47,919
Seems like the best idea. I'm throwing @sshole, The Monster, Stronger Than I Was, Bezerk, and possibly Rhyme or Reason in the bushes, replacing them with the Bonus tracks, and seeing how that flows... :lupe:

Breh does it not bother you a 41 year old MAN just ended his album with a "Ken Kaniff" skit?
 
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
42,293
Reputation
-5,967
Daps
47,689
Reppin
RENO, Nevada
Dope review, i'm cappin hard for stronger than I was though, it's a song from kims perspective which I didn't catch on the first couple listens. I gotta kinda get into bad guy, I was too anxious to hear joints like legacy and got stuck on evil twin, by the time I got to that shyt I was :banderas:

Getting ready to peep these bonus tracks and throw a couple of these pop tracks in the bushes.

there all :fire: "beautiful pain" shows why EM is the GOAT. the most diverse MC to ever walk the earth
 
Top